Mission entrance set for major restoration
Conservators for San Xavier plan to give the building's decorative facade a facelift
HENRY BREAN
Arizona Daily Star
The ornate entrance to San Xavier Mission will soon get a much-needed facelift, thanks to a $749,000 grant from the National Park Service.
Conservators for the late-18th-century church plan to spend the next two to three years carefully stabilizing and restoring the building's decorative facade, which dates back to the late 18th century and features statues of five saints guarded by a pair of lions.
The Park Service announced funding for the project on Aug. 22 as part of its Semiquincentennial Grant Program, a multi-year initiative leading up to the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States in 2026.
The grant-funded work at the mission should 'help the church survive for another 200 years,' Park Service officials said.
It's the single largest grant in the 46-year history of Patronato San Xavier, the nonprofit that oversees preservation and fund-
raising for Arizona's oldest intact European structure.
'We've had some in the quarter- of-a-million-dollar range, but this one certainly beats the band,' said Patronato executive director Miles Green.
This will be the first large-scale restoration of the mission's facade in more than 70 years. One of the primary goals of the project is to undo some of the damage done by that previous work.
During the 1940s and 1950s, San Xavier's stewards covered the entire building, including the facade, with concrete plaster made from Portland cement in hopes of strengthening the structure and protecting it from the elements. Though the work was 'thoughtfully done by the standards of that time,' Patronato officials said the plaster used back then ended up trapping moisture and damaging the centuries-old adobe material beneath it.
The first phase of the new project, set to begin in October, involves removing those 'incompatible repair materials' and stabilizing the decorative surfaces to 'retain as many of the original finishes and paint as we can,' said Starr Herr-Cardillo, conservation project manager for Patronato.
Careful copies
In future phases, the conservation team wants to reconstruct and replace key pieces of the facade that have been lost over time, including the decorative columns and the central mesquite-wood balcony.
The retablo surrounding the front doors of the church originally included 10 columns with distinctive designs, but the harsh desert climate — and a powerful earthquake in 1887 — gradually reduced them to rubble.
Only two columns remained by 1942, when they were wrapped in plaster jackets like the ones used to protect dinosaur fossils and removed for safekeeping. After 10 years in storage, though, the original material inside the jackets had dissolved into 'a crumbly mess,' Herr-Cardillo said, so plaster forms were used to create the replica columns that are seen on the building today.
Patronato plans to use historic photos of the facade to create new, more accurate replicas of all 10 original columns.
Green said the project could also include preservation work on the church's original wooden front doors, which date back to 1797 and are still in use today.
There is even some preliminary discussion of trying to recreate the statue of the church's patron saint, which once graced the top of the facade before losing its head and torso and being modified into a flagpole decades later. But that idea could prove tricky, since the statue's head was already missing when some of the earliest surviving photos of the mission were taken in the early 1870s.
Then there is the still-unsettled question of which patron saint once stood atop the church. Some scholars believe the statue depicted Saint Francis of Assisi, founder of the Franciscan order whose followers built the mission. Others are convinced it was Saint Francis Xavier, one of the original Jesuits for whom the mission is named.
If the statue ever was to be replaced, Green said, the decision about which Saint Francis could be left open to interpretation. 'It may just be Frank,' he said.
The Catholic church along the Santa Cruz River was constructed between 1783 and 1797 with kilnfi red adobe bricks and O'odham labor.
'The flags of four nations have flown over it,' Green said — Spain, Mexico, the U.S. and the Tohono O'odham Nation.
Because of the prominence of the facade, Patronato officials said all of the work on it is being done with caution, sensitivity and in consultation with church members and the surrounding community.
Slow going
Though many of the weathered or missing decorations on the front of the mission can't be restored to their original appearance, Green said the conservation team hopes to 'improve the legibility of the facade' overall so visitors can get a sense of what it might have looked like.
'There's a lot of great photo documentation,' added Herr-Cardillo, but even that has its limits.
They simply don't have enough detailed information to allow for a wholesale recreation of the original work. And even if they did, she said, they would never jeopardize what's left of the historic material to attempt such a thing. 'I think it's the job of any historian to be clear about what they know and what they don't know,' Herr-Cardillo said.
As part of their final preparations for the restoration project, conservators spent about a month early this year cautiously removing the Portland cement from the lower section of Saint Lucy's skirt in the alcove to the right of the mission's front door.
The dress rehearsal, so to speak, focused on an area roughly the size of the front page of the Arizona Daily Star.
'We wanted to know how bad it is under there,' Herr-Cardillo said. 'It was very eye-opening.'
During the 1950s restoration, workers nailed chicken wire to the original statue, coated it with a new layer of plaster and painted it using a color scheme that bore little resemblance to what had been there a century before.
Underneath that plaster, conservators found bits of the original paint, but removing the newer stuff to get to the old proved to be no easy task. 'It was a helpful reality check in terms of how slow the work is going to be,' Herr-Cardillo
